Google’s Organic Listing will be Influenced by Pay Per Click, by Mark Bove’
Google, PPC, internet marketing 1 Comment »For years it has been hotly debated as to whether or not Google would give brownie points to those who participate in their AdWords campaigns, which is a form of Pay Per Click (PPC). There are many ‘experts’ in the field who will tell you this is not the case and that there has never been an example of PPC adding to the validity or popularity of your organic rankings as the two are not one and the same. Still there has been growing speculation for some time now that Google does indeed give ‘special treatment’ to those who show them advertising dollar love and a recent study conducted by two NYU professors may have just proved the conspiracy theorists point.
According to professors in Anindya Ghose and Sha Yang in a recent study, the presence of organic listings on a search engine such as Google definitely impacts the click-through rates of PPC advertisements and the same is true for the inverse. This was the first experimental study that evaluated the impact of advertising on search engines examining all three levels of participants, which are the consumers, advertisers, and the search engines themselves, in relation to both organic listings and PPC.
If this is indeed true that Google organic listings are without a doubt being influence by PPC then why do you think that is? Google revenue perhaps? When you think about it Goggle is would be very motivated to have websites that advertise with them be at a higher ranking on their search engine. If more visitors find these websites then more visitors will have a chance to see the advertising making them more effective and thus making the website owners more likely to continue to advertise with Google. Once again it looks as though the all mighty dollar may have spoken.
Of course Google cannot come right out and admit this, nor would they if they wanted to. Organic listings are supposed to only be about SEO and relevance where as anyone can utilize PPC regardless of how SEO-illiterate you are. But just because you spend more money on the advertising side of Google’s AdWords than somebody else, does that meant that you should get top billing in the SERPs? No it does not and for those who spend many months or even years trying to accomplish top rankings the old fashion way it represents an absolute nightmare.
While the evidence is thin at this point in time there are bound to be more than just one set of professors who are curious enough to dig deeper into the on goings of Google and if and when this story is broken, it will be a bombshell. Ghose and Yang plan on releasing a paper titled, ‘Analyzing the Relationship between Organic and Sponsored Search Advertising: Positive, Negative or Zero Interdependence,’ but they have yet to say if they will charge for it or not. So in Google’s defense, these professors could just be looking to get rich quick. Then again, they may be on to something big. Even if their story is bogus it is sure to draw a multitude of interest from outside parties looking to find some dirt on the search engine powerhouse.
However, messing with Google is like messing with the Mafia and requires nerves of steel. Because Google is pretty much its own entity they have no one looking over their shoulder and are self-governed so there really are no set of rules that they have to follow that are not their own. To add to that, Google is constantly changing its own ‘rules’ on ranking and SEO requirements and if you decide that you want to cross them then you may not have to sleep with the fishes, but your website’s rankings certainly will.
Only time will tell what the truth is when it comes down to Google and the mystery of the great organic listing influenced by PPC. Just keep in mind though, it is Google, so if they do end up being in the wrong, they simply have to change the rules once again and then they will be in the right. For Google, it is good to be king.




